Why Do Diesels Pay More Vehicle Tax?
At first glance, vehicle tax for diesel cars appears unfair: the displacement rate is 9.50 euros per started 100 cc -- nearly five times the 2.00 euros for petrol vehicles. But this surcharge has a concrete reason: the energy tax (formerly mineral oil tax) on diesel fuel in Germany is significantly lower than on petrol. Per liter, diesel drivers pay roughly 18 cents less in energy tax. The higher vehicle tax is intended to partially compensate for this advantage at the pump.
Comparing Displacement Rates
The difference becomes particularly pronounced with larger engines. A 1,500 cc petrol engine pays 30 euros in displacement tax per year. A 1,500 cc diesel pays 150 euros -- five times as much. For a 2,000 cc engine, the gap widens further: 40 euros (petrol) versus 190 euros (diesel). The displacement disadvantage for diesel vehicles is therefore substantial, amounting to 120 to 300 euros per year depending on engine size.
Diesels Often Have Lower CO2 Emissions
Diesel engines are generally more efficient than petrol engines of the same power class and emit less CO2 per kilometer. For a VW Golf, for example, the 1.5 TSI (petrol) produces approximately 130-140 g/km CO2 (WLTP), while the 2.0 TDI (diesel) achieves only 115-125 g/km despite the larger displacement. This means the CO2 component of vehicle tax is lower for diesel -- partially offsetting the displacement disadvantage.
Concrete Comparison: VW Golf 1.5 TSI vs. 2.0 TDI
Let us calculate a specific example: The VW Golf 1.5 TSI (petrol, 1,498 cc, 130 g/km CO2, first registered 2024) pays: Displacement: 15 x 2.00 euros = 30.00 euros. CO2: 20 g (96-115) x 2.00 euros + 15 g (116-130) x 2.50 euros = 40.00 + 37.50 = 77.50 euros. Total: 107.50 euros per year.
The VW Golf 2.0 TDI (diesel, 1,968 cc, 120 g/km CO2, first registered 2024) pays: Displacement: 20 x 9.50 euros = 190.00 euros. CO2: 20 g (96-115) x 2.00 euros + 5 g (116-120) x 2.50 euros = 40.00 + 12.50 = 52.50 euros. Total: 242.50 euros per year.
The diesel therefore pays 135 euros more in vehicle tax per year -- despite lower CO2 emissions.
Break-Even Analysis: At What Mileage Does Diesel Pay Off?
The higher vehicle tax for diesel is partially offset by lower fuel consumption and a cheaper pump price. In our Golf comparison, the TDI consumes approximately 4.5 l/100 km while the TSI uses around 5.8 l/100 km. With diesel at 1.55 euros per liter and petrol at 1.70 euros, the diesel has a cost advantage of roughly 2.9 cents per kilometer.
To offset the 135 euros in additional tax, the Golf TDI would need to be driven at least 4,700 km per year. Above this mileage, diesel becomes cheaper overall. With typical new car usage (12,000-15,000 km/year), the diesel saves roughly 200-300 euros annually compared to the petrol variant -- despite higher vehicle tax.
Conclusion: Diesel Only Makes Sense for High-Mileage Drivers
Vehicle tax alone clearly weighs against diesel. The significantly higher displacement rate of 9.50 euros vs. 2.00 euros creates an additional burden of 100-300 euros per year. Only at annual mileages of approximately 5,000-8,000 km (depending on the model) do the lower fuel costs compensate for these additional costs. For low-mileage drivers, city drivers, and short-distance commuters, a petrol or hybrid vehicle is almost always the better choice from a tax perspective.
