R

EV Not Worth It? These Driving Profiles Are the Exception

Editorial
6 min read
2026-03-02
EV Not Worth It? These Driving Profiles Are the Exception

For Whom an EV Is Not (Yet) the Best Choice

Despite all the advantages in operating costs, there are driving profiles and life situations where an EV is not yet the best economic option in 2026. Honesty is important: the switch does not pay off for everyone. Here are the main exceptions and the reasons behind them.

Exception 1: Low-Mileage Drivers Without Home Charging

Those who drive less than 8,000 kilometers per year and have no way to charge at home face a difficult calculation. The lower operating costs cannot compensate for the higher purchase price within the usual ownership period. At only 5,000 km/year and exclusively public charging (55 ct/kWh), the EV saves only about EUR 300/year in energy costs compared to an economical petrol car. The purchase price difference of EUR 8,000 would take over 25 years to recoup.

What Makes More Sense Instead

For low-mileage drivers without charging options, an economical petrol car, a hybrid, or car sharing may be the better choice. A used EV at a significantly lower purchase price can also improve the calculation.

Exception 2: Long-Distance Commuters Without Charging Stop Tolerance

Those who drive 200 kilometers or more of highway daily and have no time for charging stops reach limits with current EVs. Range drops by 20 to 30 percent at high speeds (highway driving at 130 km/h). An EV with 400 km WLTP range often only manages 280 to 320 km on the highway.

Additionally, the highway charging network has improved but is not always reliable. Waiting times at occupied charging stations can disrupt schedules. For drivers who need to arrive on time every day, this can be a dealbreaker.

Exception 3: Budget-Oriented Used Car Buyers

Those looking for a car for EUR 5,000 to 10,000 will find a huge selection in the combustion used car market. EVs in this price range are rare and often offer lower range, as they are older models with smaller batteries. For price-conscious buyers, a used combustion car often remains the only realistic option.

Exception 4: Towing and Heavy-Load Users

EVs can tow trailers, but range drops drastically, often by 40 to 60 percent. Those who regularly tow heavy trailers, horse transporters, or caravans are often better served with a diesel SUV or van. The gap is slowly closing: models like the Mercedes EQE SUV or the BMW iX can tow up to 2,500 kg, but the range penalty remains an issue.

Exception 5: Renters Without Their Own Parking Space

Without a dedicated parking space with charging capability, charging an EV is more cumbersome and expensive. While there is a right to a wallbox in the underground garage (WEMoG law), implementation often fails in practice due to the owners' association, missing infrastructure, or high installation costs. Those who rely exclusively on public chargers pay significantly more and must plan charging times.

How the Situation Is Improving

All of the exceptions mentioned will become less relevant over time. Ranges are increasing, charging infrastructure is growing, purchase prices are falling, and the used market is expanding. By 2027 or 2028, many of these limitations may be largely gone. For those whom the EV does not yet suit: monitor developments and regularly run the TCO calculator with current values.