Pet Insurance: For Whom Is It Really Worth It?
The question of the right insurance for your pet concerns many animal owners. Between dog liability, surgery insurance and comprehensive health insurance, there are numerous options with very different prices. This guide helps with the decision.
Dog Liability: Mandatory in Many Federal States
Dog liability insurance protects against damages your dog causes to other people, animals or property. It is mandatory in six federal states: Berlin, Hamburg, Lower Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt, Schleswig-Holstein and Thuringia. Costs: 40 to 80 euros per year.
Recommendation: Always take out dog liability insurance, even if it's not mandatory in your state. A dog bite or a traffic accident caused by your dog can quickly result in damage claims of 100,000 euros or more.
Surgery Insurance: The Sensible Basic Protection
Surgery insurance covers costs for surgical procedures under anesthesia — exactly the cases that can get really expensive. Costs: 15 to 40 euros/month for dogs, 8 to 20 euros/month for cats.
What's covered: operations under anesthesia, pre- and post-treatment, hospital stays, medications related to the surgery. What's not covered: outpatient treatments, preventive examinations, vaccinations, dental treatments (unless surgical).
Typical terms: deductible 0 to 20 percent, waiting period 30 days after contract signing, GOT reimbursement up to 2x or 3x rate. Pay attention to the maximum reimbursement rate — cheap plans often only reimburse at the 1x GOT rate, which can lead to shortfalls with specialists.
Full Health Insurance: Complete Protection at a Price
Full health insurance additionally covers outpatient treatments, diagnostics (X-ray, ultrasound, blood work), medications, physiotherapy and alternative healing methods. Costs: 30 to 100 euros/month for dogs, 15 to 50 euros/month for cats.
Caution: Premiums increase significantly with the animal's age. Many insurers no longer accept older animals (from 7 to 8 years) or charge high surcharges. Pre-existing conditions are generally excluded.
For Which Animals Does Which Insurance Make Sense?
Large dog breeds: Surgery insurance almost always recommended. The common joint problems and high surgery costs quickly pay for themselves. Small dog breeds: Surgery insurance sensible, but self-provision also possible as surgery costs are lower.
Cats (outdoor): Surgery insurance recommended as accident risk is higher. Cats (indoor): Self-provision often sufficient as injury risk is lower. Rabbits, birds, fish: No sensible insurance offers available. Self-provision is the only option here.
Calculation Example: Insurance vs. Self-Provision
Surgery insurance (25 euros/month over 12 years): 3,600 euros total cost. Self-provision (25 euros/month over 12 years): 3,600 euros in savings account. The difference: With insurance, you're protected from day one. With self-provision, you only have 300 euros in reserve in the first year — too little for a major surgery.
Our Tip
Always take out dog liability insurance. Add at least surgery insurance, especially for large breeds. Compare at least 3 providers and pay attention to the GOT reimbursement rate. Take out insurance as early as possible — the younger the animal, the cheaper the premium.
