Comparing the Main Roofing Materials
When choosing a roofing material, three factors play the primary role: cost, minimum pitch and lifespan. We compare the five most common materials in Germany: clay tiles, concrete tiles, slate, standing seam metal and asphalt shingles.
Clay Tiles: The Classic Choice
Clay tiles are made from natural clay fired at high temperatures and have been the standard roofing material in Germany for centuries. They are available in numerous profiles: plain tiles (Biberschwanz), interlocking tiles (Frankfurter Pfanne), and many more.
Cost: 25 to 50 EUR/sqm (material + installation). Premium brands like Erlus or Creaton sit at the upper end. Minimum pitch: 22 degrees. Lifespan: 50 to 80 years.
Advantages: Natural building material, excellent durability, wide variety of shapes and colors, good moisture management (breathes), individual tiles easily replaceable when damaged.
Disadvantages: Relatively heavy (approx. 40-50 kg/sqm), high minimum pitch, prone to moss growth in shaded locations, inferior tiles may crack in frost.
Concrete Tiles: The Affordable Alternative
Concrete tiles (market leader: Braas) consist of cement, sand and water. They are significantly cheaper than clay tiles and offer similar performance.
Cost: 20 to 35 EUR/sqm. Minimum pitch: 22 degrees. Lifespan: 30 to 50 years (shorter than clay). They are heavier than clay tiles (approx. 45-55 kg/sqm) and can fade over time.
Slate: The Premium Material
Slate is a natural stone split into thin sheets. In Germany, Moselle slate is the best known. Slate roofs are commonly found on historic buildings in the Rhineland, Eifel and Bergisch Land regions.
Cost: 80 to 140 EUR/sqm. Minimum pitch: 25 degrees. Lifespan: 80 to 150 years (the most durable material). The material is expensive, installation requires specialist skills, and not every roofer can work with slate.
Standing Seam Metal: Light and Flexible
Standing seam metal consists of zinc-coated steel, aluminum or copper. The sheets are joined with standing seams, creating a rainproof connection. The system works for pitches from 7 degrees.
Cost: 50 to 90 EUR/sqm (steel). Copper and zinc are significantly more expensive (100-200 EUR/sqm). Lifespan: 40 to 70 years. Advantages: Low weight (approx. 5-10 kg/sqm), low minimum pitch, fast installation, low maintenance.
Disadvantages: Higher initial investment than tiles, condensation issues (ventilation required), not aesthetically suited to every building, louder than tiles in rain.
Asphalt Shingles: The Budget Solution
Asphalt shingles consist of fiberglass mat saturated with bitumen and coated with mineral granules. They are lightweight, inexpensive and easy to install.
Cost: 15 to 30 EUR/sqm. Minimum pitch: 15 degrees. Lifespan: 20 to 35 years (the shortest of all options). They are suitable for garden sheds, carports and simple roofs, but not for quality residential buildings.
Cost Comparison for a Typical Roof
For a 170 sqm gable roof (10 x 12 m, 35 degrees), approximate material costs (excluding battens and underlay): Concrete tiles: 3,400-5,950 EUR. Clay tiles: 4,250-8,500 EUR. Asphalt shingles: 2,550-5,100 EUR. Standing seam metal: 8,500-15,300 EUR. Slate: 13,600-23,800 EUR.
In addition, every roof requires battens (approx. 8-12 EUR/sqm), underlay membrane (approx. 3-5 EUR/sqm), insulation (15-40 EUR/sqm), gutters, snow guards and accessories.
